Skip to content

We may be paid when you buy through our links. Who pays us never changes what we show. How we make money

Guide: pellet vs gas

Pellet grill vs gas grill: what the same cooking area costs

Updated November 17, 2026

Twelve pellet grills from Traeger, Pit Boss and Z Grills next to eight Monument Grills gas grills, matched by cooking area. The pellet grill is the dearer buy in most size bands; Pit Boss's Carbon Series is the exception.

$0.66 vs $0.64
Price per sq in at about 525 to 545 sq in: Monument Mesa II 410BZ vs Pit Boss Carbon 500 (our arithmetic)
$0.79 vs $1.05
Price per sq in at 860 to 884 sq in: Monument 77352 vs Traeger Woodridge (our arithmetic)

Monument Grills, Traeger, Pit Boss and Z Grills product pages, read Oct 29, 2026. See source

Glowing embers and smoke in the dark.
On this page
  1. Key facts
  2. Where to start
  3. Pellet vs gas by cooking area, listed October...
  4. What the price buys on each side, from the pages
  5. The eight Monument Grills gas grills, listed O...
  6. See the gas grills on Monument Grills' site
  7. Pellet vs gas price questions
  8. Sources

Key facts

  • Monument Grills sells gas grills, not pellet grills. Its store listed 500 items on Oct 29, 2026 and none of them is a pellet grill, so every Monument row on this page is a propane or natural gas grill18.
  • Same size, different price. At 630 to 653 sq in, the Monument Mesa 415BZ lists at $499.00 and the Traeger Westwood at $699.99; at 860 to 884 sq in, the Monument 77352 is $699.00 while the Traeger Woodridge is $899.99561112.
  • Pit Boss is the pellet grill that undercuts gas. The Carbon Series 700 lists 718 sq in for $379.99, about $0.53 a square inch; no Monument grill on this page is below $0.66315.
  • The small end is where gas is cheapest by far. A 200 sq in Monument G22 tabletop grill is $199.00; a 176 sq in Traeger Ranger pellet grill is $479.9919.

Where to start

Where to start
If you are askingStart withLink
Cheapest way to 500 to 550 sq in?Monument Mesa II 410BZ $349.00 or Pit Boss Carbon 500 $349.99
Cheapest per square inch on this page?Pit Boss Carbon 700, about $0.53 (pellet)
A gas grill around 900 sq in?Monument 77352 $699.00 or Denali 605 $729.00
Why pick pellet at all?Wood smoke and set-temperature control; see what the pages say

Pellet vs gas by cooking area, listed October 29, 2026

Each band pairs the grills whose total cooking area is closest. Cooking area and price are as each maker's page states them; price per square inch is our arithmetic on the total area. Rows with a button are Monument Grills gas grills.

GrillFuelTotal cooking areaListed pricePrice per sq in
Tabletop and small portable, 176 to 256 sq in
Monument Grills G221See the pagePropane200 sq in$199.00$1.00
Traeger Ranger9See the pageOpens Traeger's site. Not a referral link.Pellets176 sq in$479.99$2.73
Pit Boss portable (battery powered)17See the pageOpens Pit Boss's site. Not a referral link.Pellets256 sq in$499.99$1.95
Portable, 300 to 450 sq in
Monument Grills Mesa 200S (foldable)2See the pagePropane450 sq in$359.00$0.80
Traeger Tailgater10See the pageOpens Traeger's site. Not a referral link.Pellets300 sq in$499.99$1.67
Mid-size, 525 to 572 sq in
Monument Grills Mesa II 410BZ3See the pagePropane525 sq in$349.00$0.66
Monument Grills Mesa 3254See the pagePropane570 sq in$399.00$0.70
Pit Boss Carbon Series 50014See the pageOpens Pit Boss's site. Not a referral link.Pellets543.3 sq in$349.99$0.64
Traeger Pro 2213See the pageOpens Traeger's site. Not a referral link.Pellets572 sq in$549.99$0.96
Large mid-size, 630 to 718 sq in
Monument Grills Mesa 415BZ5See the pagePropane630 sq in$499.00$0.79
Traeger Westwood11See the pageOpens Traeger's site. Not a referral link.Pellets653 sq in$699.99$1.07
Z Grills 700D4E WiFi with cabinet18See the pagePellets697 sq in$877.00$1.26
Pit Boss Carbon Series 70015See the pageOpens Pit Boss's site. Not a referral link.Pellets718 sq in$379.99$0.53
Large, 860 to 900 sq in
Monument Grills 77352 (rotisserie kit included)6See the pagePropane880 sq in$699.00$0.79
Monument Grills Denali 6057See the pagePropane or natural gas900 sq in$729.00$0.81
Monument Grills Eminence 605 (rotisserie and cover included)8See the pagePropane or natural gas860 sq in$1,349.00$1.57
Traeger Woodridge12See the pageOpens Traeger's site. Not a referral link.Pellets860 sq in$899.99$1.05
Traeger Pro 3413See the pageOpens Traeger's site. Not a referral link.Pellets884 sq in$699.99$0.79
SourceProduct pagesRead Oct 29, 2026Product pages (spec tables)Read Oct 29, 2026Product pages, default optionRead Oct 29, 2026Our arithmeticRead Oct 29, 2026

Above 900 sq in Monument lists nothing, so the band stops there; the pellet side continues with the Z Grills 10502B (1,080 sq in, $777.00, about $0.72 a square inch) and the Pit Boss Sportsman 1100 (1,610 sq in, $849.99, about $0.53). Monument's totals include its secondary or warming rack area, as its spec tables state them; the pellet makers quote one total figure. Struck-through prices on the Monument pages are not used.

What the price buys on each side, from the pages

Fuel and heat. A pellet grill feeds hardwood pellets from a hopper into a fire pot and holds a set temperature; the pellet pages here top out at 450 F to 500 F, with Pit Boss adding a direct-flame slide it rates to 1,000 F111417. Monument's gas grills run on a propane tank (the Denali 605 and Eminence 605 pages also offer natural gas) and the store quotes preheat figures instead of a top setting: 500 F in 5 minutes on the Mesa II 410BZ, 650 F in 10 minutes on the Mesa 415BZ, 700 F on the Denali 605 and 800 F on the Eminence 6053578. None of these pages compares the two fuels, and we have cooked on none of these grills.

What is counted as cooking area. Monument's spec tables split each total into primary and secondary area: the 77352's 880 sq in is 640 sq in of primary space plus a 240 sq in warming rack, and the Denali 605's 900 sq in is 640 plus 26067. Traeger, Pit Boss and Z Grills quote one figure for their pellet grills121518. Where you want a like-for-like main grate, compare Monument's primary figure (640 sq in on all three large models) with the pellet total.

Burners and output. Monument states total BTU on every page: 15,000 on the two-burner G22, 37,000 on the four-burner Mesa II 410BZ, 62,000 on the Mesa 415BZ with its sear and side burners, 84,000 on the six-burner 77352 and Denali 605, and 89,000 on the Eminence 605 including its rear rotisserie burner135678. Pellet grill pages do not state BTU; their capacity figures are hopper size and runtime, for instance Z Grills' 28 hours on a full 28 lb hopper for the 700D4E18.

Warranty lines. The Monument Mesa, 77352 and Denali pages each carry an '8-Year Limited Warranty' line; the G22 and Eminence 605 pages read '10-Year Limited Warranty'12678. Pit Boss states a 3-year warranty on the Carbon Series and 5 years on its portable grill1417. Read the full terms on the maker's page before you order; the lines above are what each product page says, not the policy document.

What is in the box at the listed price. Two Monument prices on this page include extras: the 77352's $699.00 option includes a rotisserie kit, and the Eminence 605's $1,349.00 default option includes the rotisserie and a cover68. On the pellet side, Z Grills' $877.00 is the '700D4E Grill + Free Gifts' option18. Everything else is the grill alone.

The eight Monument Grills gas grills, listed October 29, 2026

Cooking area, burners and BTU are the store's spec-table figures; the price is the default option on each page.

Gas grillTotal area (primary + secondary)BurnersTotal BTU the store statesListed price
G22 tabletop1See the page200 sq in (200 + none)215,000$199.00
Mesa 200S foldable2See the page450 sq in (320 + 130)224,000$359.00
Mesa II 410BZ3See the page525 sq in (405 + 120)437,000$349.00
Mesa 3254See the page570 sq in (405 + 165)3 + side burner48,000$399.00
Mesa 415BZ5See the page630 sq in (450 + 180)4 + sear burner + side burner62,000$499.00
77352 (rotisserie kit included)6See the page880 sq in (640 + 240)6 + side burner84,000$699.00
Denali 6057See the page900 sq in (640 + 260)6 + side burner84,000$729.00
Eminence 605 (rotisserie and cover included)8See the page860 sq in (640 + 220)6 infrared + rear burner + side station89,000$1,349.00
SourceMonument Grills spec tablesRead Oct 29, 2026Monument Grills product pagesRead Oct 29, 2026Monument Grills spec tablesRead Oct 29, 2026Monument Grills product pages, default optionRead Oct 29, 2026

Five of the eight pages showed a higher struck-through price next to the listed one on Oct 29 (G22 $219.00, Mesa 200S $369.00, Mesa II 410BZ $369.00, Mesa 325 $439.00, Denali 605 $799.00, Eminence 605 $1,429.00); the Mesa 415BZ and the 77352 did not. Each page also prices bundles with a cover, smoke box or conversion kit; those are on the store's pages and are not repeated here.

See the gas grills on Monument Grills' site

Eight gas grills listed on October 29, 2026. Prices and specifications are from each product page.

Good for pricing a gas grill against the pellet grill of the same cooking area

Monument Grills gas grills

Listed range
$199.00 to $1,349.00 across eight models
Cooking area
200 to 900 sq in total, per the store's spec tables
77352 stainless propane gas grill with rotisserie kit (880 sq in)
$699.00 (rotisserie kit included)
Denali 605 stainless smart tech natural/propane gas grill (900 sq in)
$729.00 ($799.00 struck through)
Eminence 605 stainless natural/propane gas grill with rotisserie and cover (860 sq in)
$1,349.00 ($1,429.00 struck through)
G22 stainless tabletop propane gas grill (200 sq in)
$199.00 ($219.00 struck through)
Mesa 200S foldable stainless gas grill (450 sq in)
$359.00 ($369.00 struck through)
Mesa 325 black propane gas grill (570 sq in)
$399.00 ($439.00 struck through)
Mesa 415BZ stainless propane gas grill (630 sq in)
$499.00
Mesa II 410BZ stainless propane gas grill (525 sq in)
$349.00 ($369.00 struck through)
Checked
Oct 29, 2026
What to check before you buy
  • Propane tank or natural gas line, per model
  • Assembled size against your patio space
  • Shipping, warranty terms and what the option includes, on the store's page

Pellet vs gas price questions

Is a pellet grill more expensive than a gas grill of the same size?

On these pages, usually. Matched by cooking area, the Monument gas grill lists below the Traeger or Z Grills pellet grill in every band: $499.00 against $699.99 at about 640 sq in, $699.00 against $899.99 at about 870 sq in. Pit Boss's Carbon Series is the exception: $349.99 for 543.3 sq in and $379.99 for 718 sq in, both at or under the Monument grill of that size.

Does Monument Grills make a pellet grill?

Not that its store lists. On Oct 29, 2026 the store's 500 items were gas grills, parts and accessories; the only item with 'pellet' in its name is a charcoal/pellet flame tamer accessory. That is why every Monument row here is a gas grill.

What does price per square inch leave out?

Everything but price and area: fuel, hopper size, heat range, controller, warranty length and what is in the box. It is our arithmetic (listed price divided by the total cooking area the page states) and a way to line the sizes up, not a verdict.

Why does the Eminence 605 cost $1,349.00 for 860 sq in?

Its page lists six infrared main burners, an 11,000 BTU rear burner with the rotisserie included, a side searing station, Bluetooth app control, an LED display and a 10-Year Limited Warranty line, and the default option includes a cover. Per square inch it is the dearest grill on this page, gas or pellet.

Which pellet grill is cheapest per square inch here?

The Pit Boss Carbon Series 700: 718 sq in for $379.99, about $0.53 a square inch on Oct 29, 2026, the same figure as the much larger Sportsman 1100 (1,610 sq in for $849.99).

Were these prices checked on the same day?

Yes. Every Monument, Traeger, Pit Boss and Z Grills figure on this page was read on Oct 29, 2026 from the page in the sources list, and the Monument prices were cross-checked against the store's product data for the same model.

Sources

  1. G22 stainless tabletop propane gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  2. Mesa 200S foldable stainless gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  3. Mesa II 410BZ stainless propane gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  4. Mesa 325 black propane gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  5. Mesa 415BZ stainless propane gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  6. 77352 stainless propane gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  7. Denali 605 stainless smart tech natural/propane gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  8. Eminence 605 stainless natural/propane gas grillMonument Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  9. Ranger portable pellet grillTraeger, read Oct 29, 2026
  10. Tailgater portable pellet grillTraeger, read Oct 29, 2026
  11. Westwood pellet grillTraeger, read Oct 29, 2026
  12. Woodridge pellet grill (four sizes)Traeger, read Oct 29, 2026
  13. Pro 34 pellet grill, Bronze (Pro 22 price on the same page)Traeger, read Oct 29, 2026
  14. Carbon Series 500 wood pellet grillPit Boss, read Oct 29, 2026
  15. Carbon Series 700 wood pellet grillPit Boss, read Oct 29, 2026
  16. Sportsman Series 1100 wood pellet grillPit Boss, read Oct 29, 2026
  17. Portable battery powered wood pellet grillPit Boss, read Oct 29, 2026
  18. 700D4E WiFi pellet grill with cabinetZ Grills, read Oct 29, 2026
  19. 10502B WiFi XL pellet grillZ Grills, read Oct 29, 2026

About this page

We may be paid when you buy through links on this page.

We may be paid when you buy through links on this page.

Prices, specifications and shipping belong to each merchant and can change. The merchant's own page is the final word on price, availability and terms.

PelletPick compares published specifications. We have not cooked on these grills, and nothing here is a test result or a ranking.